HD DVD

Bandits and bricked hardware

Given today's major news, this seems almost irrelevant to mention, but what it likely to be last ever HD DVD purchase came slinking into the house today in the guise of Ridley Scott's American Gangster. Somewhat fitting, given the format's sorry end, it turned out to be a less than stellar release from Universal (gee, now there's a surprise). I've said before that, when they release a title sourced from a digital intermediate (DI), they generally manage to deliver a flawless or at least very good image. When it comes to film-sourced material, though, the results are rarely so positive, and American Gangster, despite being a recent title, is one of these. Evidence of noise reduction and a general lack of fine detail conspire to make this a deeply underwhelming presentation.

Unfortunately, I couldn't investigate the disc any further because, this afternoon, my brother's Xbox 360, presumably in mourning over the demise of HD DVD, popped its clogs. Given that it will have to be returned to the US to be either repaired or replaced, it's going to be out of action for some time, so this evening I decided to order a stand-alone HD DVD player, a Toshiba HD-EP30.

I know, I know, I'm probably the only person in the world who'd buy a player the very day the format was officially pronounced dead, but I have my reasons. For one thing, we've been yearning for an HD DVD player that could do 24p output for some time (the Xbox 360 is limited to 60 Hz playback). For another, today's incident hammered home just how accident-prone the console is, and, with that in mind, I'd rather have a stand-alone device on which to play my existing HD DVD collection rather than having to rely on there being a fully functioning Xbox 360 to connect to my HD DVD add-on drive. And finally, it was a mere £77.99 from Amazon.co.uk (with two free titles thrown in for good measure). While I have no doubt that the price will drop even lower in the coming weeks, the fact remains that I have a copy of The Bourne Ultimatum sitting on my shelf that I really need to review for DVD Times. And I'm impulsive.

Universal, you tramp!

Source: High-Def Digest

Universal Studios Home Entertainment has officially announced that it will release its titles on Blu-ray.

Though details of the studio's transition away from HD DVD were still sketchy at press time, Universal Studios Home Entertainment President Craig Kornblau officially confirmed the move in a just issued statement:

"The path for widespread adoption of the next-generation platform has finally become clear. Universal will continue its aggressive efforts to broaden awareness for hi-def’s unparalleled offerings in interactivity and connectivity, at an increasingly affordable price. The emergence of a single, high-definition format is cause for consumers, as well as the entire entertainment industry, to celebrate. While Universal values the close partnership we have shared with Toshiba, it is time to turn our focus to releasing new and catalog titles on Blu-ray."

Wow - they sure moved fast, didn't they? HD DVD isn't even twenty-four hours in the stone cold earth and they're already hopping into bed with their former partner's bitterest rival. The big question, I suppose, is whether they'll continue to release titles on HD DVD for a short period, like Warner, or simply scrap any plans to release anything more on what is now officially a dead format.

So, did anyone hear today's big news?

It was fun while it lasted.

HD DVD
R.I.P.
March 31st 2006 - February 16th 2008

Not quite giving up the ghost

Source: High-Def Digest

Toshiba is denying weekend press reports that it has decided to drop its HD DVD support, saying that the company is "currently assessing its business strategies," but that no final decisions have been made.

In an official statement issued this morning, Toshiba said, "The media [has] reported that Toshiba will discontinue its HD DVD business. Toshiba has not made any announcement concerning this. Although Toshiba is currently assessing its business strategies, no decision has been made at this moment."

At this stage, I strongly doubt that there's any saving HD DVD. This is simply a case of prolonging the agony, and I personally believe that it would be for the good of all concerned if Toshiba simply threw in the towel and released Universal and Paramount from whatever contracts are still binding them to the format. Still, things don't look quite as clear-cut as they did the other day.

Light a candle for HD DVD

Source: DVD Times

Japanese broadcaster NHK has just announced Toshiba's intention to withdraw from the HD DVD format. NHK says that Toshiba's factory has already ceased production of HD DVD equipment, although it will still be available on sale for the time being. This is the final blow to the ailing format, which has been on a downward slide since being dropped by Warner Bros earlier this year.

If you didn't believe the fat lady had sung, you'd better believe it now. Read the full suicide note at Reuters.

Choice = good, waxy faces = not

I'd just like to take a minute to commend TF1 Vidéo for the subtitling options they have provided for their Blu-ray (and presumably HD DVD as well, but I bought the Blu-ray version) release of La Môme (released outside France as La Vie en Rose). Not only is it that rare beast, a French disc which caters to English speakers, it also includes two different variants of subtitle for both English and French.

The first is what the menu describes as "pour lecture sur écrans plats" (for reading on flat screens), which positions the subtitles at the bottom of the screen, overlapping on to the letterboxing. Some people like this, but I don't, as it means my eye is drawn to the letterboxing rather than the image itself. It is also a pain in the neck for those with projection displays who routinely mask the letterboxing for 2.35/9:1 ratio discs. Unfortunately, the majority of Blu-ray and HD DVDs that I have seen deliver their subtitles in this fashion.

Luckily, TF1 has supplied a second subtitle stream, "pour lecture en vidéoprojection", which places the subtitles (smaller than the "flat screen" ones) within the picture frame itself. This looks much more natural and avoids any masking problems, and I really wish more studios would provide this sort of choice for the consumer.

As for the transfer itself, it's largely pleasing (an AVC encode from a digital intermediate source), but unfortunately seems to be have been subjected to the same sort of noise reduction that also affected the UK release of Pan's Labyrinth to some degree (and the US release to a much greater degree). While the detail remains largely intact, textures, particularly the actors' skin, tend to take on a rather waxy appearance, and sequences shot in low lighting conditions (i.e. ones that would normally appear grainier) suffer more noticeably than those taking place in broad daylight. It's not horrible, but it's really not the sort of thing I like to see on my HD discs (although I'm coming more and more to expect this sort of digital manipulation, sadly).

The disc, by the way, arrived last Saturday, but, in my lazy fatigue, I forgot to post about it. (I ended up sleeping for thirteen straight hours that night, so you can perhaps forgive the oversight!)

Early warnings from Warner

Source: High-Def Digest

Warner has announced some of the high profile titles forthcoming coming to Blu-ray (and DVD) over the course of the next year (covering the rest of 2008 and early 2009). These include, in Q2 2008, a Dirty Harry Ultimate Collection, a Batman Anthology in Q3, and, looking further ahead, Gone with the Wind, North by Northwest and The Wizard of Oz in 2009. You can certainly pencil me in for a copy of North by Northwest, which has been one of my most anticipated titles for high definition treatment since the possibility was initially raised at Warner's Home Theater Forum chat in February 2007.

Obviously, don't expect to see any of these titles on HD DVD, given that Warner is cutting its ties with the format at the end of May... although Batman Begins did see a (decidedly sub-par) HD DVD release back in 2006.

We are as gods... oh, wait, those halos aren't meant to be there

As you can probably tell by the title of this post, the HD DVD release of Asterix and the Vikings isn't perfect. It is, however, somewhat better than The Simpsons Movie, which is comparable in that it is one of only a very small number of digitally sourced, 2D animated titles released in high definition (the others I've seen being the very good-looking Les Triplettes of Belleville on HD DVD and the deeply underwhelming Paprika on Blu-ray).

The Simpsons movie was filtered, resulting in noticeable ringing around outlines, and so is Asterix, only less so. In many of the captures posted below, the ringing is difficult to miss, but it could have been a lot worse, and only results in a small reduction in the overall detail levels (I have some unfiltered 1920x1080 publicity stills to compare with the DVD captures). Compression is generally very good, despite the low bit rate, although, on a related note, there is some of the banding commonly associated with gradients in digitally-sourced animated features (see Shot 1), as well as a strange horizontal line artefact in a handful of shots (look closely at Asterix's hair in Shot 11). I previously saw this on the Platinum Edition DVD of The Jungle Book, so I'm wondering if it's another issue common to digitally sourced animation.

Unfortunately, both audio tracks (English and French) are out of sync, lagging slightly behind the video. It's incredibly distracting, since, given the nature of animation timing, even knocking the sound out by three or four frames can be very noticeable.

Astérix et les Vikings
(M6 Vidéo, France, VC-1, 12.9 GB)

Hello, it's me, I'm back from the sea

Well, not literally, because I wasn't anywhere near the sea. But it is indeed me, and I am indeed back. As I mentioned previously, I was away at my gran's funeral, which was held down in Warwick, meaning that we had to head down a day early and come back a day late. I'm not sure what I can really say about it ("I'd give this funeral a 6/10" doesn't sound quite right), except that the cremation was set to a piece of music by Ennio Morricone, chosen by my aunt. Unfortunately, it wasn't anything daring like the opening title theme to Four Flies on Grey Velvet, which would have been an eye-opener indeed (although I do think Come un Madrigale could have worked), but rather a piece from one of his Hollywood projects, The Mission.

Anyway, over the last three days, I've spent about twenty hours sitting in the back of a car, so I'm understandably not feeling entirely loquacious at the moment. Just a quick note to say that the French HD DVD release of Asterix and the Vikings and the US Blu-ray release of Volver were waiting for me when I got back this evening, so I'll be discussing them in due course. Hopefully tomorrow, but I've had very little sleep over the last couple of nights, due to a variety of factors, so I'll be hitting the hay before too long. I need to be up at 6:30 for work anyway.

PS. Thanks for all the well-wishing, people. For those who asked, no, this was not exactly an unexpected death. My gran had Dementia and had been going south for a long time. She more or less spent the last month of her life unconscious, and I think most of us would have agreed that it was better for her to go now than to hang on in there without any real quality of life.

DVDs I bought or received in the month of January

• 28 Weeks Later (RA USA, Blu-ray)
• Cat People (R0 USA, HD DVD)
• Eastern Promises (R0 USA, HD DVD)
• Factory Girl (R2 UK, DVD)
• Little Children (R2 UK, DVD)
• Munich (R2 UK, DVD)
• Pan's Labyrinth (R0 USA, HD DVD)
• The Plague Dogs (R2 UK, DVD)
• The Simpsons Movie (RA USA, Blu-ray)
• Y Tu Mamá También (R2 UK, DVD)
   

What's so bad about a little ADHD?

Perhaps I've been a bit hard on Michael Bay. Armageddon and Pearl Harbor may be awful excuses for films, and my brother doesn't have a single kind word to say about Bad Boys 2, but everything else that I've seen from him has entertained me to some degree. The Rock is undoubtedly his best work, and Transformers, while far too long and filled with bad attempts at humour and tedious robot fights, is actually quite fun at times.

I've now seen the UK HD DVD release The Island, his solitary box office flop, and I have to say that I did like it, despite it being little more than a poorly disguised knock-off of Logan's Run (hardly the best film to use as your source material in the first place). Like all of his films, it demonstrates the aesthetic sensibilities and world view of a teenager, but I'm going to buck the trend and say that I don't think Bay is a completely incompetent filmmaker. True, he may overuse fast cutting and shakycam to an obnoxious degree, but he certainly knows how to shoot and stage a chase scene, which The Island has in abundance, and he seems to have a knack for getting nicely lit tight close-ups of the Beautiful People™ (and the not so beautiful). I can't defend it as a great work of art or even anything particularly thought-provoking (although I'm sure you could make a case for it being Bay's anti-stem cell research film if you put your mind to it - hey, he is a Bush supporter, after all), but I had fun, which, when all said and done, about all you can really ask from a summer blockbuster.

The HD DVD transfer (not doubt the same as what is to be found on the Blu-ray release), by the way, is pretty nice, albeit with some caveats. The look of the film is very similar to that of Transformers, but, unlike that particular HD DVD, someone was let loose with the filters of nastiness. There is a light sheen of edge enhancement at all times, particularly noticeable in wide shots and in Bay's trademark "posing in front of the sun" money shots, not to mention some light compression artefacts in some of the more action-intensive shots - a by-product, I suspect, of capping the bit rate to ensure that it would fit on a single layer BD-25. Still, a good presentation all in all, with a solid audio mix. I'd consider picking up a copy if I found it in a sale somewhere.

The Island
(Warner, UK, VC-1, 20.6 GB)

Hangin' on in there

Source: High-Def Digest

Universal has once again reiterated its commitment to HD DVD, claiming that it has no plans either to abandon the format or make any changes to its current strategy. This statement is not altogether surprising, and should probably be taken with a pinch of salt given that, a little as three weeks before its surprise switch to Blu-ray exclusivity, Warner was still claiming that it had no plans to alter its stance of neutrality. Still, regardless of how you feel about the situation (I'm of two minds about it, personally), it does at least sound as if we can expect to see plenty of new material from Universal in the near future, rather than them crawling into a hole and hiding till it's all over.

Lots of grain and gristled chins

I watched the HD DVD release of Running Scared last week. I can't say I particularly warmed to the film it all, unfortunately. On paper, it sounds like an interesting premise (a minor gangster is charged with disposing of a gun used to kill an undercover cop, but the kid living next door to him steals it, uses it to shoot his abusive father and runs off, prompting the aforementioned gangster to head off on a madcap chase through the city to track the kid down and get rid of the gun), but, as is usually the case with me and gangster movies, it didn't click at all. I found it all a bit boring, to be perfectly honest, with the occasional inspired idea (the climax, set at an ice rink, is pretty unique) not really doing enough to hold it all together. It's a shame, because I really liked writer/director Wayne Kramer's earlier film, The Cooler. Ah well, you win some, you lose some.

At least fans of the film will not be disappointed with the HD transfer. EMS has given this movie a stellar presentation, accurately depicting the film's heavily stylised, contrasty, grain-wrought appearance. Given the often jittery camerawork, and the fact that it is the moving grain particles that gives the film much of its detail, the static screenshots below might not completely do it justice, but take my word for it, this is a very, very nice transfer, and one that would probably have been in my personal Top 10 (or at least Top 15) transfers of 2007 if I'd seen it in time for it to qualify.

Running Scared
(EMS, Germany, VC-1, 20.9 GB)

Not so import proof after all

Remember the post I made last week where I said that Germany HD DVD publisher Senator Home Entertainment was going Blu-ray exclusive? Well, guess what: they're not. That's right, it was all a load of hooey.

Apparently, Cinefacts, who first reported the false story, got the "news" direct from the Blu-ray Disc Association (the BDA), but have now retracted the announcement. So, once again, the BDA have been caught lying. Well I never! Unfortunately, whoever said that cheaters never prosper clearly never bore witness to a format war.

This is hardly going to save HD DVD, but it does mean that we should be able to get region free HD releases of the likes of Death Proof and Planet Terror.

The DVNR bandits strike again

The other day, I ordered a copy of the soon-to-be-OOP US HD DVD release of Pan's Labyrinth from New Line. I did this fully aware of the controversy surrounding the noise reduction that had been applied to the transfer, sucking out much of the grain and fine detail. My reasoning behind this was that the UK release, which I reviewed late last year, also showed signs of noise reduction, so I figured that both would feature the same decent but flawed transfer, with the US release having the added benefits of lossless 7.1 audio, picture-in-picture and other additional extras.

Unfortunately, it looks as if I was wrong. Screen captures have surfaced at the AV Science Forum showing, in their full 1920x1080 resolution, the same frame from both releases (as well as the French HD DVD and EU H.264 broadcast versions), and to say that the US release makes the UK version look stellar would be an understatement. This is probably the worst example of grain-sucking I've seen on an HD release this side of Cat People or American Psycho, and while many people are predictably praising the US release for looking "smooth" and "clean" (words which always put the fear of Pazuzu in me when used in reference to material shot on film), the more informed among us are justifiably outraged.

I'm now really sorry I ordered this release, and at this rate I won't even be bothering to unwrap the cellophane. It also makes me slightly suspicious of the rave reviews that New Line's other HD releases have been receiving, and I have a feeling I'll need to pick up one or two of them to get to the truth of the matter. The problem is that none of the titles they've put out so far appeal to me, least of all Rush Hour 3.

Import proof

Apparently, German distributor Senator Home Entertainment, currently an HD DVD distributor, will be following in Warner's footsteps and dropping support for the format to concentrate exclusively on Blu-ray.

Among the various titles the format owned the rights to and planned to release on HD DVD were the two halves of Grindhouse, Planet Terror and Death Proof, the latter of which was even listed on Amazon.de and which I had pre-ordered. With it now unlikely to see the light of day, I've cancelled my order.

The sad part of this is that, so far, Senator's Blu-ray releases have apparently been region coded, which means that, unless I supplement my Region A Playstation 3 with a Region B model, I probably won't be able to play any eventual Blu-ray releases of these two films. Aren't you just loving this new Blu future?

HD banditry

Although they have been floating cover art, vague specs and a "coming soon" release window for some time now, Universal have, until today, not unveiled many specifics about their upcoming HD DVD release of Ridley Scott's latest film, American Gangster.

Today, however, they issued an official announcement, confirming its release date as February 19th, along with its full specs. This will be an HD DVD/DVD combo release, and, oddly enough, while the HD DVD side contains only the theatrical cut, the DVD side, via seamless branching, also throws in what is being described as an "Unrated Extended Cut", clocking in at 19 minutes longer than its theatrical counterpart.

My first reaction upon reading this announcement was "No!!! You morons! What are you thinking releasing it like this?" The more that I think about it, though, the less this annoys me. Does anyone remember the last Ridley Scott film to be released as an "Unrated Extended Cut" (as opposed to a "Director's Cut")? It was Gladiator, and it opened with a visibly pissed off Scott, scarcely able to hide his contempt, telling us that the version we were about to release was categorically not his director's cut. The fact that he and writer Steven Zaillian have provided an audio commentary for the theatrical version rather rather than the extended cut suggests to me that this is their preferred version. I wouldn't be at all surprised to discover that the extended version was just another Gladiator, with a few scenes that were rightly left on the cutting room floor spliced back in.

Bottom line, it would have been nice to have had both versions in HD, but I'm not losing sleep over this. Unlike some people, I'm not about to cancel my pre-order.

I am, however, disappointed to note that many of the extras from the DVD have been left off this release... although it may turn out that much of the missing material may be replicated in the picture-in-picture feature on the HD DVD.

Now this is more like it

Last night, Lyris and I watched his recently-acquired HD DVD of the Director's Cut of Zodiac. Like Crank (see here), it was shot entirely in the digital realm, but unlike Crank, it didn't have a bunch of chimpanzees fiddling with the image control knobs. Zodiac continues Paramount's winning streak for new releases, with a virtually flawless transfer that makes the standard definition release appear even more embarrassing than it did already. If you look very closely, you can see a teeny tiny bit of sharpening, which I suspect was added during post production (the on-screen text, such as credits and location type, are unaffected), but otherwise this is one of the absolute best presentations of a movie I've ever seen (at least in a technical sense - I'm personally not a fan at all of the completely grain-free look).

Zodiac: Director's Cut
(Paramount, USA, AVC, 24 GB)

Universal still loves you

Source: High-Def Digest

After almost a week of ominous silence, Universal has finally made a public statement regarding its HD DVD support. As some of you will know, the studio's exclusivity deal with the format expired recently and has, as yet, not been renewed, prompting rumours ranging from it going format neutral to going Blu-ray exclusive and abandoning HD DVD completely à la Warner. While I don't think anyone in their right mind would doubt that we'll be seeing Universal titles on Blu-ray be the end of the year (if not the end of the month), those who are currently HD DVD-only will probably be quite relieved to hear that

"Contrary to unsubstantiated rumors from unnamed sources, Universal's current plan is to continue to support the HD DVD format," said Ken Graffeo, executive vice president of HD strategic marketing for Universal Studios Home Entertainment and co-president of the HD DVD Promotional Group.

In addition,

A Universal spokesperson told us this afternoon that the studio plans to issue new upcoming HD DVD title announcements in the near future.

We shall see...

There's life in this old Bolshevik yet

Well, the news of Warner's switch to Blu-ray's exclusivity and expected demise of HD DVD may have stolen the headlines, but the format certainly isn't going to vanish overnight. Before Universal and Paramount move over to Blu-ray as well, hammering the final nail into HD DVD's coffin, I will continue to buy new releases that are exclusive to the format.

One of these is Eastern Promises, which arrived this morning. I wasn't too taken by David Cronenberg's previous two films, Spider and A History of Violence, but this one, while very much a companion piece to them, for some reason appealed to me much more. Maybe it's the excellent cast, including Naomi Watts, Viggo Mortensen, Sinéad Cusack and Vincent Cassel, but the other two films had stellar talent in front of the camera as well (including Mortensen, in the case of A History of Violence). Maybe it's the fact that the London location resonates with me more than Violence's small-town America - but then again, Spider was also set in London. It's not even the subject matter, since gangster movies generally irritate me. (Not that this is a typical gangster movie in any sense: for one thing, the gangsters in this film don't say "fuck" in every sentence and call each other "faggots" every five minutes. For another, it's not shot in near-black and white, headache-inducing shakeycam.) I don't know why, but this one really clicked for me, and I'm sorry I didn't get to see it before the end of 2007, because, if I had, it would have garnered a pretty high position in my annual Top 10.

Oh, and the HD DVD transfer is also solid, proving once again that Universal's standard for DI-sourced material is among the best (the less said about their track record for catalogue releases, though, the better). It looks to have been slightly degrained, and it isn't as razor sharp as something like Resident Evil: Extinction or The Bourne Ultimatum, but it is a pleasant, rich, detailed image with no visible compression problems. And Naomi Watts doesn't look half bad occupying 130" of my wall.

Eastern Promises
(Universal, USA, VC-1. 15.7 GB)