Individual Entry

 
 

 
The Giallo Project #3: Blood and Black Lace

DVD

Alternative titles: Sei donne per l’assassino; Director: Mario Bava; Starring: Cameron Mitchell, Eva Bartok, Thomas Reiner; Music: Carlo Rustichelli; Italian theatrical release date: March 14th, 1964

Whenever the topic of Blood and Black Lace comes up, I always seem to find myself apologising for not liking it more. I’ve seen it four or five times now, and on each occasion I find myself feeling strangely distanced from it and unable to see it in quite the same light as its many, many admirers. Maybe it’s the fact that it lacks a single clear-cut protagonist to whom I can relate, or perhaps it’s because, to date, there has not been a satisfactory presentation of the film on DVD (it’s fickle, I know, but there have been occasions when a better transfer has improved my appreciation of a film, particularly those that are visually-oriented). In any event, for whatever reason, Blood and Black Lace is an entry that I see as important on account of its influence, but considerably less interesting when taken on its own merits.

Dubbed “the first authentic body count movie” by VCI on the cover of their (frankly pretty poor) DVD release, Blood and Black Lace builds on the thematics that Bava developed in his previous two gialli, The Girl Who Knew Too Much and The Telephone segment of Black Sabbath, and injects a vital new component that would come to characterise so many other films in the genre: the protracted, deliriously violent murder sequence. While Girl’s death scenes, such as there were, were pretty perfunctory, they are Blood and Black Lace’s raison d’être, and are quite shocking in their intensity. The very first, occurring in a windswept park at night within the first five minutes, is brutal and frenzied, unveiling the fedora-clad, black-gloved killer (his face concealed with a mask), who, thanks to his sheer viciousness and lack of identifying features, feels more like a force of nature than an actual person.

Blood and Black Lace

Actually, it’s difficult to fault the murders at all - they are all incredibly well-executed and almost always incredibly sadistic. One unfortunate victim is slapped about before having her hand and then face scalded, while another receives a blow to the face with a spiked glove, prefiguring the killer’s modus operandi in Death Walks at Midnight by several years. A further death, occurring late in the film, also sets the template for many a giallo bathtub drowning. However, the scenes designed to connect them together (and I believe that this is all they really are) are considerably more mundane, with the plot never sustaining my interest in that way that Girl’s does. Thomas Reiner’s wooden Inspector Silvester plods from scene to scene without doing anything particularly interesting, and the various women of the fashion house around which the events revolved are given only enough characterisation for us to know what dirty deeds they have been getting up to in between shows.

Admittedly, some of this really is quite clever. In typical giallo form, everyone is hiding something, whether it’s drug addiction, thievery or blackmail, and to an extent you can almost imagine the killer representing a force of brutal retribution. Bava also indulges in one of his favourite pass-times in opening up an outwardly respectable society and revealing it to be corrupt to the core. Furthermore, I don’t need to tell you that it’s impeccably shot, with Bava’s trademark gel lighting giving the various locations an otherworldliness while still anchoring them firmly in reality. However, Blood and Black Lace remains, for me, a stepping stone in the giallo’s journey rather than the landmark that many consider it to be. I like it, but I would never afford it masterpiece status.

Sorry again…

Next time, I’ll be looking at Michelangelo Antonioni’s seminal Blowup (don’t worry - all will be explained).

 
Posted: Monday, August 20, 2007 at 3:07 PM | Comments: 2
Categories: Cinema | Gialli | Reviews | The Giallo Project

 
Comments

1.

I guess it has a lot to do with what people like and how each and every person's own tastes/preferences are.

I love "Blood and Black Lace" not only for it's gorgeous cinematography but also for the very reason you had described, all the stuff that is going on at the high society / fashion enviroment (Backstabbing, Betrayal, Lies, envy). It's typical pulp stuff, a soap opera such as "Bold and the Beautiful" with murders. That's why I think it's very interesting in a highly campy/titilating kind of way.

When it comes to a man protagonist for example, the movie may also suffer from that. "Deep Red" is a movie I love and a lot of people like the David Hemmings character, but that's the main weakness in this movie for me. I can't sympathize with how the character is portrayed/written (weak, unsympathetic and conservative - although all of these factors may serve the subtext) nor do I like the portrayal by the actor.
But Tony Musante in "Bird" is a very clichee-d and one-dimensional protagonist I sympathize with and find very likeable - that may not be the case for a lot of people, but I for one do think he is likeable.

Looking forward to the next chapter in your project.

Posted by: Kamyar-MZ, August 20, 2007 9:34 PM

2.

Interestingly, I don’t think Tony Musante in Bird is clichéd or one-dimensional at all - in fact, I think he shares many of the same traits as David Hemmings’ character in Deep Red, and is considerably less likeable than him - for all his prejudices, Marc Daly never treats Gianna in the frankly horrendous way Sam Dalmas treats Giulia (although that probably has a lot to do with the fact that Gianna would never let anyone treat her in that way).

Anyway, regarding Blood and Black Lace, I’m well aware that I’m in the minority regarding my opinion of it, but it doesn’t change the fact that I just don’t find it that interesting outside of the murders and a couple of other key sequences (the one involving the handbag being left on the table during the fashion show is a definite highlight that I wish I’d mentioned in my original post). Something about many of Bava’s films always leaves me feeling a little distanced, and I get that with Blood and Black Lace far more than, say, The Girl Who Knew Too Much, which had a plot that held my interest throughout its duration.

Posted by: Whiggles, August 21, 2007 10:41 AM

Comments on this entry and all entries up to and including June 30th 2009 have been closed. The discussion continues on the new Land of Whimsy blog:

https://www.landofwhimsy.com

 

 
 
Back to...